Advanced Search | Help

  HOME     |    TOPICS     |    BACK ISSUES     |    EVENTS     |    NEWS    



  
Reprints & Linking Info   Printer-Friendly    Email this Article        Font Size     What's This?


[Special Report]
Unrealistic Expectations Threaten WiMAX's Success
The industry must stop hyping WiMAX in order to recognize where the specification is now, what it must overcome, and the other issues that stand between it and world domination.

Nancy Friedrich
September 2004

1) Locked Your Keys In The Car? Get Out Your Cell Phone  92
2) The Bigger The Better? Or Do Good Conferences Come In Small Packages?  90
3) Unrealistic Expectations Threaten WiMAX's Success  62
4) Effective WLAN Testing Begins To Emerge  56
5) Transmit And Receive Diversity Comes Alive  52
ALL TOP 20 >>

Despite some great charitable and technological efforts, the disparity between the world's networked and non-networked populations seems only to have worsened. The better-connected populations are enjoying a move to next-generation cellular standards and wireless personal-area networking. Meanwhile, many impoverished areas don't even have landlines or Internet access. In the countries that do have a communications infrastructure, only the cities and their surrounding areas enjoy the newest, higher-speed services. In the rural areas, high-speed access is unattainable—for now.

Thanks to an emerging broadband-wireless-access (BWA) technology, such rural areas may soon enjoy high-speed access. Known as WiMAX (IEEE 802.16), this specification was spawned out of the ever-multiplying IEEE 802.xx family. According to the WiMAX Forum (www.wimaxforum.org), 802.16 can be used to backhaul 802.11 hot spots and wireless-local-area networks (WLANs) to the Internet; provide campus connectivity; and enable a wireless alternative to cable and DSL for last-mile broadband access (SEE FIGURE).

Of course, the capabilities that are described above only apply to one form of WiMAX: the 2-to-11-GHz specification for wireless-metropolitan-area-network (WMAN) technology. Even in this early, pre-product stage, multiple WiMAX variations are already being tossed around (SEE SIDEBAR).

Ken Wetherell, Wi-LAN, Inc.'s (www.wi-lan.com) VP of Corporate Communications and Investor Relations, summarizes them this way:

  • 802.16a addresses 2-to-11-GHz, licensed (2.5-, 3.5-, and 10.5-GHz), and unlicensed (2.4- and 5.8-GHz) frequencies. It is non-line-of-sight (NLOS) compatible.
  • 802.16b targets license-exempt applications around 5 to 6 GHz (the U-NII bands).
  • 802.16c adds interoperability with other frequencies (10 to 66 GHz).
  • 802.16d, which has been renamed 802.16-2004, consolidates 802.16, 802.16c, and 802.16a with an expansion of the band to include all frequencies below 2 GHz.
  • 802.16e adds mobility enhancements for the media-access-controller (MAC) layer. It is expected to be ratified by the third quarter of next year.

Thanks to the consolidation within 802.16-2004, that specification and 802.16e have now become WiMAX's two main focuses. Yet people are still confusing early facts about 802.16a with the evolution of WiMAX now. If the current confusion over WiMAX isn't resolved, it could hurt the specification's progress. According to Phil Belanger, BelAir Networks' (www.belairnetworks.com) VP of Marketing, "WiMAX can operate from 2 to 11 GHz. (Newer 802.16 variants cover some higher-frequency bands.) It can be licensed or unlicensed. It can be fixed wireless or mobile. It uses FDD or TDD, depending on the frequency band. It operates at 70 Mbps at ranges up to 50 km. The hype about WiMAX takes all of the capabilities and rolls them into one."

Obviously, the industry at large needs to get better acquainted with WiMAX and all of its nuances. Many are looking to the WiMAX Forum for this clarification. It's widely noted that this forum has largely followed the successful model of Wi-Fi standards development. From those roots, it continues to flourish. The WiMAX Forum has gained the backing of leading wireless-chip-set companies like Intel and Fujitsu as well as more enterprise-focused companies, such as Proxim. Recently, many service providers also have become involved. Impressively, the forum has succeeded in getting this wide range of companies—many of them competitive—to agree on a single standard.

Many believe, however, that the forum hasn't done enough to get the public better acquainted with WiMAX. If it doesn't more clearly and realistically communicate the specification's capabilities, the current hype could affect WiMAX's future success. (Think back to the excitement that almost killed Bluetooth before it was born.)

Both the industry and the public need to know the truth about WiMAX: the real potential of its variants, its known limitations, potential areas of concern, and the specification's roadmap. Like every other technology, WiMAX is sure to encounter problems and obstacles. Doug Grant, Analog Devices' (www.analog.com) Director of Business Development, RF & Wireless Systems, lists a few areas of concern: "It might be oversold and set unrealistic expectations for consumers. All wireless systems—particularly in the UHF/microwave spectrum—have limitations. Obstacles like trees and buildings can block signals and result in a frustrated user. Unlike satellite-based systems, in which a directional antenna can be aimed at the sky, terrestrial systems have local impairments. There is also danger in people using unlicensed spectrum and being disappointed in the performance in environments where there are other users in the same (unlicensed) frequency band."

Physical obstacles and other users probably aren't the only path to unhappy consumers, however. The old RF enemy, interference, is very likely to rear its head in the unlicensed spectrum. Every RF technology is susceptible to interference. The question is what will cause it. WLANs are one potential culprit. Despite the hype, WiMAX is predicted to work with wireless LANs—not make them obsolete. Due to this co-existence, WLANs could act as interferers. The same can be said of cordless phones.

Essentially, interference could arise between WiMAX and any wireless service that inhabits the same frequency bands—including itself. Airpath Wireless' (www.airpath.com) CEO, Todd Myers, notes that WiMAX could interfere with other WiMAX hot zones due to a lack of regulation regarding potential placement opportunities.

The issues surrounding WiMAX's use of unlicensed spectrum will undoubtedly be critical to its performance and—by extension—its success. Yet WiMAX also must arm itself for the global spectrum battle. Walt Burns, Director of IT Wireless Network Solutions for Unisys Corp. (www.unisys.com), notes, "International spectrum allocations are anything but uniform. WiMAX technology can utilize a wide swath of both licensed and unlicensed bands. But regulatory issues in various countries have the potential to box it in and limit its potential for performance, reliability, and ubiquity. This translates into fewer companies making new product with lower volumes and higher costs."

The threat of limited market penetration is the thread that runs through all of the potential obstacles to WiMAX. The first WiMAX products are expected toward the end of this year. More products are on the horizon for 2005. If these products aren't widely adopted, the specification's ability to target new applications will be hindered.


<-- prev. page     [1] 2     next page -->




[Reader Comments]
Unrealistic Expectations Threaten WiMAX's Success

sdadas
- Submitted On: May 13, 2008
runescape money runescape gold runescape gold runescape money buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape money runescape gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft Power Leveling Warcraft PowerLeveling buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape itemsrunescape accounts runescape gp dofus kamas buy dofus kamas Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold runescape money runescape power leveling runescape money runescape gold dofus kamas cheap runescape money cheap runescape gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium Hellgate money Tabula Rasa gold tabula rasa money Tabula Rasa Credit Tabula Rasa Credits Hellgate gold Hellgate London gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft PowerLeveling Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling eve isk eve online isk eve isk eve online isk tibia gold Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold runescape money runescape gold wow power leveling

Name (required):FD
- Submitted On: April 20, 2008
Reflecting on wow power leveling ideas, I was wow power leveling very happy wow power leveling it explained a wow power leveling of things. First, a wow power leveling of parents complain wow power leveling what impact games wow goldon children, but wow powerlevelingthose parents are generally only wow powerlevelingseeing the trivial wow powerleveling of the game, rather wow powerlevelingwhat the game is REALLY teaching. Chess wow goldto be vaguely about war (it has knights and castles and kings), but it's world of warcraft power leveling a game of controlling space, of world of warcraft power leveling the opponent's mind, of twow power leveland tactics and so on. Grand wow power level Auto appears to be about power leveling wow cops and hookers, but it's power leveling wow a game of power leveling wow and freedom. There is value topowerleveling wowa virtual world that lets you do powerleveling wow you can't do in thecheap wow power leveling world. Don't be fooled by the gangster facade.Even more to Raph's point, I Maple Story mesos on what Street Fighter MapleStory mesos me: anms mesos lot. Wheremesos even begin? SilkRoad Gold starters, there's tactics SRO Gold strategy. When SilkRoad Online Gold you attack and when eq2 plat you? You have eq2 goldunderstand the eq2 Platinumpoints in EverQuest 2 Platinummatch, the EverQuest 2 gold thatEverQuest 2 plat the lotro gold open. If you lotr gold winning, you Lord of the Rings online Gold to avoid these situations, if you're losing you need to create them. Street Fighter taught me about yomi: knowing the mind of the opponent. You can't just play the odds and do the textbook-correct responses, you have to adapt and anticipate your opponent's moves. The game is merely a medium through which you play against the other player. Some players develop skills in planning, while others develop theirRolex Replica at improvisation Replica Rolexadapting to any situation they are thrown into. I learned first hand that when all seems lost, if you push, push, push and never give up, it's still possible to win.

ss

Name (required):TGYHT
- Submitted On: April 10, 2008
Tell us what you think - post your comments here.cheapest, best service have it on wow gold . so many wonderful things you can enjon it not only cheapest price,best

distrubition,all from wow leveling, warcraft power leveling warcraft gold promptly,best service only

get it from wow power leveling FFXI Gil Buy FFXI Gil FFXI Gil Sale Cheapest FFXI Gil Buy Cheap FFXI Gil final Fantasy XI Gil Cheap FFXI Gil

Name (required):ryht
- Submitted On: April 6, 2008
Tell us what you think - post your comments here. cheapest, best service have it on wow gold . so many wonderful things you can enjon it not only cheapest price,best distrubition,all from wow leveling, warcraft power leveling warcraft gold promptly,best service only get it from wow power leveling FFXI Gil Buy FFXI Gil FFXI Gil Sale Cheapest FFXI Gil Buy Cheap FFXI Gil final Fantasy XI Gil Cheap FFXI Gil

Name (required):ryht
- Submitted On: April 6, 2008
Tell us what you think - post your comments here. cheapest, best service have it on wow gold . so many wonderful things you can enjon it not only cheapest price,best distrubition,all from wow leveling, warcraft power leveling warcraft gold promptly,best service only get it from wow power leveling FFXI Gil Buy FFXI Gil FFXI Gil Sale Cheapest FFXI Gil Buy Cheap FFXI Gil final Fantasy XI Gil Cheap FFXI Gil

Name (required):wewe
- Submitted On: March 4, 2008
Tiffany & Co specialises in quality handcrafted designer siliver jewellery tiffany co jewelry jewelry life jewelry brand tiffany jewelry tiffany sterling silver necklace bracelet ring earrings. We features a variety of items including Tiffany inspired jewelry, Bulgari inspired jewelry GUCCI Jewelry fashion jewelry tiffany jewelry for jewelry chains jewelry

Name (required):hoang
- Submitted On: April 25, 2007
Tell us what you think - post your comments here.

READER COMMENTS:
We want to hear what you have to say about this article!



Enter the text from the image below


Please refresh the page if you have trouble reading this text.

     
Your email is only used if our editors need to contact you.
Connection Failure



PartFinder

Find real-time pricing, stock status, same-day/next-day shipping options and more. Brought to you by Digi-Key. Go to PartFinder.    
GlobalSpec

PART SEARCH :
Powered by: GlobalSpec - The Engineering Search Engine
Marketplace

Introducing Lantronix’s Most Secure Embedded 802.11b/g Networking Module
Add wireless networking to virtually any electronic device with the highest levels of security with the MatchPort® b/g Pro. SmartRoam technology allows seamless mobile connectivity and improved reliability. Low power consumption mode option available.
Free Measurement and Control Handbook
Keithley’s “Understanding New Developments in Measurement, and Control,” is a guide to high-performance test and measurement applications and techniques. Order your copy by calling 1-800-588-9238.
Download Free Whitepapers and eBooks
Check out the full selection of whitepapers and ebooks available today on Electronic Design
Sponsored Links

Electronic Design Europe Electronic Design China EEPN Microwaves & RF Schematics
Electronic Design Military Electronics Featured Vendors EE Events Free Design Resources



Planet EE Network Home | Contact Us | Editorial Calendar | Media Kit | Headlines | Site Feedback & Bugs
Copyright © 2008 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Legal | Privacy